“Hope After Easter”
Luke 24:13-35
Daniel J. Ott
Eatser is such a hopeful time. We come together as Spring is blooming. We wear bright colors and adorn our sanctuaries with beautiful flowers. We sing hymns about Jesus’ victory over sin and death in the resurrection. Our hearts and minds are buoyed by the festive atmosphere and we almost can’t help but feeling hopeful.
But what about hope after Easter? How do we sustain that hope after Easter? Actually, the liturgical calendar tells us that there are seven Sundays of Easter, of which we are celebrating the third today. Perhaps we’re supposed to sustain all of the colors and music and festivities of Easter throughout these seven weeks. But even if we did that, would that keep hope alive? It seems to me that it can be difficult to keep hope alive after Easter.
One reason that it’s difficult to keep hope alive after Easter is because there are so many reminders that evil persists after Easter. While we testify that Jesus’ resurrection has destroyed the powers of sin and death, we also know that we do not live in the fulfillment of this victory. Our minds are quickly pulled away from the mystery and splendor of Easter back to the real world where examples of fear and hatred and violence abound.
The two travelers in our story today had this problem too. They had heard the first Easter proclamation. The women had told them that the tomb was empty and that angels had appeared telling them that Jesus was alive. But when Jesus visits them unawares as they walk and asks them what they’re talking about, it’s clear that the horrific scenes of the week before were foremost in their minds, not the hope of resurrection. Luke says they stood there sorrowfully when Jesus asked them what had happened. And we can surely sympathize with them. They had thought that Jesus would be the prophet for which they were waiting. They thought that this one finally would be the one to liberate Israel, to get rid of the Roman occupiers, to cast out the forces of evil and to restore Israel’s faith in God. But the unthinkable had happened. Their leaders had become fearful of Jesus. Their own leaders turned on their only hope. They gave him over to the vicious Romans who tortured and executed him. Their savior had been killed and their hope had been crushed. The women’s story of an empty tomb was simply not sufficient to move them past the horrors of the cross. The reality of violence and evil kept them from fully embracing the mystery of Easter.
I felt sort of jolted out of the mystery and hope of Easter myself as, early this week, I booted up the computer and saw the headline that Osama bin Laden had been killed. This news immediately brought back to mind the events of September 11, 2001, of course. I remembered the scenes from that day as I read further into the article: the planes hitting the buildings, the people running through the streets covered with soot, the rescue workers scrambling about trying to do what they could. Soon I reached the part of the article that described crowds who spontaneously gathered at the White House and at Ground Zero to celebrate bin Laden’s death. It brought back to mind the scene shown after 9/11 of Palestinians flooding into the streets to dance and cheer. I remember trying in vain to understand what kind of hatred and fear could inspire that sort of response to violence and death. This week I was forced to wonder the same about my own compatriots.
It seems that we live in a world so consumed by hatred that not only do we perpetuate violence, but we revel in it. It seems that we live in a world so clouded by sin and evil that we think its right to celebrate violence and death rather than striving with all our hearts for reconciliation and new life. It’s hard to have hope after Easter in such a vicious and violent world.
But I suppose Jesus would admonish me as he did his disciples for losing hope even in the face of such evil. “You fools,” he scolded them, “how could you be so slow of heart and not believe.” I’ll be honest – I would rather Jesus would have been a little more understanding of the disciples. After all, they were being asked to believe something completely unfathomable. The resurrection is hard to believe.
I’ll tell you, I’ve heard at least one too many Easter sermons that tried to explain or even prove the resurrection. The preacher takes you through the events almost like a detective or a lawyer would, showing how the resurrection was completely plausible. But when I read the Easter stories in scripture, what jumps out at me is how even the first disciples had a hard time believing. Nobody was completely sure they should trust the women’s story. Everyone – Peter, Thomas – wanted first-hand proof. They wanted to be able to see and touch the resurrected Jesus. And we’d like to have some sort of confirmation too, but the truth is that believing in the resurrection is not a matter of proof – it’s a matter of the heart.
Jesus doesn’t admonish the disciples for being dumb or for ignoring the facts. He admonishes them for being slow of heart. And notice what he does to help them. He doesn’t recount the details about how he was raised from the dead. In this story, he doesn’t invite them to touch his hands and his side. In this story, he hasn’t even yet revealed his identity. Instead, in order to build back their faith and their hope, Jesus takes them through the scripture.
I imagine that he started with Moses and reminded them how the people were brutalized and enslaved, but they had faith and called out to God, so God delivered them. He asked them to remember that they wandered in the desert for forty years, and even though they had their weak moments, their hope for the Promised Land kept them going. He opened the prophets to them. He reminded them that even in the face of foreign aggression, exile and defeat, the prophets implored the people to turn back to God and put their trust in God alone. I imagine he got all the way into Isaiah and reminded them that there would be one who was despised and rejected, wounded for our transgressions and crushed for our iniquities, sent to the grave with the wicked even though he had done no violence. But out of his anguish we would see light. I imagine Jesus closed his sermon with Isaiah’s vision of a new heaven and a new earth wherein hunger and violence and sin and death will be stamped out forever.
But, you know what, even at the end of that rousing sermon, the disciples didn’t yet fully understand. They didn’t recognize Jesus yet. They still didn’t fully believe that resurrection story. They still hadn’t yet found their hope after Easter.
But they did like Jesus’ message, so they invited him to dinner. Then a marvelous thing happened. They sat down to a meal. Jesus took bread, blessed and broke it, and gave it to them. Sound familiar? Well, it did to them too. It was then, that they recognized him. It was then that they realized why that sermon on the road was so heart-warming. It was then that they hurried back to the others gathered in Jerusalem. It was then that the shout went up, “Christ is risen indeed!”
And this is how it happens for us too, I think. This is how we keep the hope alive after Easter. We gather here together and we remember God’s presence with God’s people. We open the scripture and remember how God has always sided with the humble and the meek. We read these stories about how the faithful always somehow sustained their hope even in the face of sorrow and tragedy and evil. We gather together and we support each other. We lift each other up and give each other an encouraging word. We gather together and we break the bread and we say our prayers and we sing our hymns. And some how, mysteriously, when we do these things are eyes are opened and our faith is renewed. Our hope is reborn and we’re inspired to shout, “Christ is risen indeed!”
I had a colleague who taught politics at the college where I taught in North Carolina. He was a Marxist and an atheist, but he went to the Presbyterian church in town almost every Sunday. For some reason, none of us ever really asked him why. One day when a bunch of us were sitting at lunch it finally came up. “Why do you go to the Presbyterian church?” Like a good professor, he answered the question with a question of his own, “Where else, today, do people get together to talk about things that really matter.”
Friends, I want you to know that I do believe that what we say and do here really matters. Rehearsing these stories of faith matters. Repeating these prayers of confession and forgiveness and reconciliation matters. Singing these hymns of assurance and joy matters. Breaking the bread in commemoration of Jesus’ death and resurrection matters. Washing ourselves in the waters of rebirth matters. Most of all, keeping hope alive – keeping hope alive even in the face of sin and death, and violence and hatred – keeping hope alive even though it’s not easy – keeping hope alive even though it’s a great mystery – keeping hope alive after Easter matters.